Tag Archives: Volusia County Sheriff’s Office

Mom in DeBary theft case must repay doctor $100K, judge says







When she ran a DeBary doctor’s office, Tisha Krutsinger stole more than $100,000 from her boss for such expenses as tanning sessions, plane tickets and a maid for her house, records allege.

Now the former office manager is under orders to repay Dr. Humberto Dominguez at a rate of $1,000 per month.

But Krutsinger, 43, says she can’t afford to pay and is asking for the court to give her a break. She can’t make the payments, citing severe financial hardships and mounting health-care bills.

“I was clearly in the wrong committing this crime, and I know that my behavior was deserving a punishment,” Krutsinger wrote in a letter last month to a Volusia County judge. “I can offer no excuses, but instead state categorically that I am truly very sorry that I broke the law and it will never happen again.”

Her request for leniency and a lower monthly restitution payment was denied.

Tisha Kurtsinger

Circuit Court Judge James R. Clayton sentenced Krutsinger in June,  finding her guilty of grand theft over $100,000.

She entered a no-contest plea.

In July, Clayton put her on community control for 12 months followed by 108 months of probation. He also ordered the $1,000 per month payments to Dominguez.

“This is putting great strain on my family as well as my health,” Krutsinger wrote. “I will have to foreclose on my home, declare bankruptcy and forego any more medical treatment if this continues. At this time I am barely able to feed my family and I am truly concerned and very scared as to the future of myself and my children.”

Dominguez realized there was a problem with his finances after his credit card was declined in May 2014, around the same time Krutsinger was fired.

He later learned Krutsinger had a credit card issued in her name that was linked to the doctor’s business, deputies say.

At the time, the doctor didn’t realize Krutsinger had been charging large sums of money and then paying them with funds from his personal bank account, a Sheriff’s Office spokesman said in 2014.

The doctor confronted her and she admitted making the personal purchases, saying she would repay him. He fired her on May 27 and called the Sheriff’s Office for help.

“Mere minutes after Krutsinger was escorted out of the office, the doctor learned that the mortgage payments on his office building hadn’t been paid for several months and foreclosure proceedings had been initiated,” the spokesman said.

The spokesman said detectives discovered that she issued an extra payroll check to herself and took cash advances on the doctor’s credit card.

She used the money to pay for her cellphone, auto insurance, car repairs, cable, orthodontic bills and a plane trip to Kansas City, deputies allege.

Records show the Volusia County Sheriff’s Office successfully seized the couple’s 2006 GMC Yukon and a 2004 Land Rover because they had both been linked to the crimes.

Sign up for DeBary Life updates:

TISHA to Judge

DeBary felon flips off deputy, gets tires flattened

A DeBary felon flipped off a deputy before officers flattened the tires of his SUV on Interstate 4 in Deltona, records show.

Jonathan Kral, 42, remained behind bars after his alleged crime spree Friday.

Jonathan KralAfter stopping, Kral yelled at officers to shoot him and a deputy had to tackle him to get him into handcuffs.

Kral was charged with fleeing and eluding, resisting an officer with violence and other crimes.

Kral’s second arrest this month

It was his second arrest this month. He was arrested Dec. 6 in DeBary, accusing of driving without a valid license.

He threatened to kill officers and said a Jihad was coming to take out citizens, records show.

Kral is being held without bond at the Volusia County Branch Jail in Daytona Beach.

Behind the wheel

Kral was behind the wheel of a red Ford Explorer that passed too close a deputy conducting a traffic stop on U.S. Highway 17-92 and Saxon Boulevard just before 7 a.m. Dec. 16.

Sgt. Keith Peck attempted to stop the SUV at Saxon Boulevard east of Enterprise Road, but the vehicle continued moving.

Peck used his spotlight to get the driver’s attention. He later activated his siren, which was also ignored.

As the vehicle got into the turn lane to go east on Interstate 4, Peck turned off the siren and pulled alongside the vehicle when it was stopped for traffic.

Giving the ‘middle finger’

“Sgt. Peck pointed the spotlight into the driver’s area and could clearly see the driver eating something and then he gave Sgt. Peck the middle finger and continued to get on the highway,” a report said.

Peck followed, going under the speed limit, about 60 to 64 miles per hour, while other officers set up tire-deflating stop sticks on the highway at I-4 and State Road 472.

The sticks hit the right side tires and the right rear went flat.

The SUV pulled over at Mile Marker 115.

Kral got out and Peck drew his handgun, ordering the suspect to the ground. He refused and yelled at Peck to shoot him. Kral was talking to someone on his cellphone.

Officer tackled Kral

Peck holstered his firearm and drew his stun gun. But Kral was wearing a heavy coat – a factor that could impede the stun-gun’s impact.

Peck ran up behind Kral and tackled him to the ground and held him there until other officers arrived. He continued to resist, trying to throw off Peck. When after backup arrived, Kral continued to fight back, moving his head back and forth and scraping his face on the ground.

He was eventually cuffed and placed in a patrol vehicle. He threatened to kill deputies and fight them.

Deputies found marijuana, pot pipes and pills.

Long criminal history

Deputies later determined he had a 27-page criminal history, including 10 felonies, according to the Volusia County Sheriff’s Office.

He served less than a year in state prison for an October 2012 charge of aggravated assault and a May 2013 child-abuse charge, records show.

He was taken into state custody in July 2013 and released in March 2014.

Sign up for DeBary Life updates below:

DeBary murder suspect Anton Sanders left hateful message, report said

The Sanford man accused of fatally stabbing a DeBary woman in her home left behind a profanity-laced message on his ex-girlfriend’s answering machine, a new document shows.

Anton Sanders, 45, is being held without bond in the Volusia County Branch Jail in Daytona Beach on a charge of first-degree murder.

The ex-boyfriend is accused of killing 51-year Lisa Bresie in her home on Lantana Drive.

In his arrest affidavit, released this week, deputies said they found her body and spotted multiple stab wounds while conducting a well-being check. They also found a message from Sanders on her answering machine, the affidavit said.

It was mostly profanity.

A family member and a friend told deputies Sanders had abused Bresie in the past and they broke up sometime this summer. They had not seen her since Nov. 1 and were concerned about her safety.

Sanders was with her vehicle when the Florida Highway Patrol responded to a report of an impaired man showing signs of distress along Interstate 275 in Pinellas County on Thursday, the Sheriff’s Office said.

He had her blood-spattered Hyundai and the keys to her vehicle.

Sanders, also wearing blood-stained clothing, tried to throw himself over a wall that separated the highway from the water below during questioning by the Florida Highway Patrol.

He was transported to a hospital in St. Petersburg as a precaution.

“Sanders was transported to a local hospital for medical evaluation and subsequently admitted to the hospital due to a high amount of cocaine in this body,” a report released this week said

During an interview with officers at the hospital on Nov. 6, he admitted they were no longer a couple but said she would let him drive her car on times.

The Volusia County Sheriff’s Office on Monday said a fingerprint found in blood inside the house came back as a match to Sanders.

Sign up for DeBary Life updates below:

DeBary prescription-drug dropoff today

Hey, DeBary residents. Got pills you don’t need?

Join thousands of others across the country today by cleaning out your medicine cabinets of unwanted and unneeded prescription drugs during National Prescription Drug Take-Back Day.

The dropoff location in DeBary is at the Volusia County Sheriff’s Office district station at 79 S. Charles Beall Blvd., DeBary.  Call  (386) 668-3830 for details.

It’s easy. It’s free. It’s safe.

“No questions asked. This is a great way to prevent drug addiction, overdose deaths or accidental ingestion by children,” Laura Williams, a spokeswoman for the Volusia County Sheriff’s Office said in a statement.

The DeBary location is among roughly 5,000 across the country participating in the drug-safety, environmentally friendly initiative.

“Disposing of leftover painkillers or other addictive medicines in the house is one of the best ways to prevent a member of your family from becoming a victim of the opioid epidemic,” DEA Acting Administrator Robert W. Patterson said in a statement. “More people start down the path of addiction through the misuse of opioid prescription drugs than any other substance. The abuse of these prescription drugs has fueled the nation’s opioid epidemic, which has led to the largest rate of overdose deaths this country has ever seen.”

Three other locations in Volusia County are also taking unwanted pills:

  • 1691 Providence Blvd., Deltona; (386) 860-7030
  • 1435 U.S. 1, Suite D-3, Ormond Beach; (386) 323-0151
  • 101 E. Canal Street, New Smyrna Beach; (386) 423-3301

The dropoffs are open from 10 a.m. to 2 p.m.

“For those who miss Saturday’s event, the Sheriff’s Office offers a continuous program where residents can drop off unwanted prescription drugs at a district office or make arrangements to have a deputy pick up their unwanted prescription medicine by calling the Sheriff’s Office’s Communications Center (386-248-1777),” Williams said.

More than 4,000 jurisdictions — including local, tribal, and community partners — are participating, the DEA said.

“The effort will help prevent these drugs, including opioids, from falling into the wrong hands and contributing to a lethal drug abuse epidemic in the United States,” the U.S. Department of Justice said in a statement.

“The DEA action comes just days after President Donald J. Trump announced the mobilization of his entire Administration to address drug addiction and opioid abuse by directing the declaration of a Nationwide Public Health Emergency to address the opioids crisis,” the statement added.

More than 450 tons (900,000 pounds) of prescription drugs were turned in at nearly 5,500 dropoffs in April.

“Today the United States is facing the worst drug crisis in our history, as more Americans are dying from drug overdoses than ever before,” U.S. Attorney General Jeff Sessions said in a statement. “We lose one American life to drugs every nine minutes. This crisis affects every American, as it is filling up our emergency rooms, our foster homes, and our cemeteries.”

Sign up for DeBary Life updates below:





DeBary Burger King armed robbery suspect has violent past, records say


The felon accused in last week’s armed robbery at the DeBary Burger King has a violent criminal past, both as a juvenile and an adult, records show.

Mathew H. Juan, 32, is being held on $150,000 bond at the Volusia County Branch Jail in Daytona Beach.

Juan was arrested minutes after Wednesday’s robbery and faces charges of robbery with a firearm/deadly weapon and false imprisonment.

Prison record

Records show Juan served more than three years in state prison before he was released in December 2012.

He was adjudicated guilty in Volusia County in 2007 after pleading no contest to charges of aggravated battery and aggravated assault.

Juan was accused of attacking his wife’s brother with a baseball bat in Edgewater.

He was placed on probation in 2007 case but was charged the following year for violating his probation. That was for his arrest on a misdemeanor domestic-violence charge.

Juvenile record

Details of that case weren’t immediately available. However, his wife testified during a hearing that Juan placed his hand over her mouth while they were arguing. She said she couldn’t breathe and she bit his hand.  Neighbors realized they were fighting and called police.

At that hearing, a prosecutor said Juan had an extensive juvenile arrest record, including arrests for criminal mischief, aggravated assault/battery,  carrying a concealed weapon and possession
of alcohol by a person less than 21.

The hearing was a day before Juan’s 24th birthday.

Xanax blamed

During her testimony, his wife defended Juan saying his violence in both cases — the baseball-bat attack and the domestic-violence incident — were caused by Xanax (alprazolam).

He took the anti-anxiety drug because of depression following a friend’s murder, she testified.

But sedative made him violent, she added. She begged a judge to keep him out of prison so he could get treatment and help raise their then 2-year-old child.

A different judge later sentenced Juan to five years in prison with credit for 153 days in jail and five years of probation.

Letter to judge

He entered the state prison system in March 2009 and left in December 2012.

In December 2015, Juan sent a letter to a Volusia County judge, seeking early termination of his probation. Juan, then an Orlando resident, said he hadn’t gotten in trouble and he was following all of the court orders.

He said he wanted to go to France to meet his in-laws. His wife, who wasn’t named in the letter, was the love of his life. And they were expecting a child, he wrote.

He started a successful business, bought his first home and had never before felt so happy and blessed.

The judge terminated the probation the following month.

Burger King robbery

In the most recent case, deputies were called to the Burger King at 11:33 a.m. June 21

“Witnesses told responding deputies a male suspect displayed a gun, robbed the employees at two registers and ran out with cash,” the Sheriff’s Office said. The robber fled into nearby woods.

A silver Ford SUV later took off out of those same woods.

“At 11:46 a.m., an Orange City police officer spotted the suspect vehicle in the area of Saxon Boulevard and Threadgill Place in Orange City and conducted a traffic stop,” the Sheriff’s Office said.

2 witnesses ID suspect

Deputies responded to the scene with two witnesses who identified Juan as the suspect. Deputies said they think he was homeless.

“Deputies also recovered cash from the wooded area near the Burger King where the SUV had been parked,” the Sheriff’s Office report said. “At the scene of the traffic stop, deputies noticed a piece greenery stuck to the back of the vehicle, as if it had been recently parked amid some brush and vegetation.”

Sign up for DeBary Life updates below:

Leave your comments below:

DeBary official: Fay-like storm will flood city

Even though DeBary is inland, a roughly 40-minute drive from the nearest beach, hurricanes remain a threat. Storm veterans remember the River City’s flooding in 2004 and 2008.

Now, even after the city installed  $30 million with of stormwater upgrades, the flooding threat remains, Public Works Director Alan Williamson told the City Council on Wednesday.

Tropical Storm Fay dumped close to 24 inches of rain in 24 hours on parts of West Volusia in 2008, overflowing lakes, putting streets underwater and flooding 130 homes in DeBary.

This hurricane season, which started June 1 but typically doesn’t kick into high gear until August and September, is expected to be a “little more than active,” Williamson said.

Weather officials are predicting 14 named storms, with 7 of those turning into hurricanes and three of those becoming major hurricanes,  Williamson said.

DeBary’s fledging stormwater system is doing a good job with routine storms. But a 2-foot deluge in one day would overwhelm the city’s system of pipes, pumps, ponds, hoses and lakes.

“If we have another Tropical Storm Fay,  we’re going to have flooding, even though we’ve spent a lot of money and we’ve put in a lot of infrastructure. Now, the flooding won’t be as bad. We can move the water much more quickly but we still have a lot of low areas in DeBary,” Williamson said.

He’s concerned about residents’ level of preparedness.

“The public won’t be ready. The public’s not ready. There’s a lot of complacency within the nation. ‘This disaster won’t happen to me. It can’t happen to me.’  Why not?” he asked rhetorically, “Whenever there’s a disaster in a small area, you always hear people say, ‘we didn’t think it would happen here.’ Why not? you need to assume the worst everywhere.”

He said the city has taken other steps besides making the stormwater upgrades. Officials have contracts in place with businesses to remove debris quickly after the storm.

A temporary disposal site has been identified. The Orange City Fire Department and the Volusia County Sheriff’s Office will provide whatever services is needed from their agencies, according to Williamson said.

The city has pumps to move water out of local ponds and generators to power traffic lights if they go out.

But residents need to prepare for their specific needs in case of storms.

“That’s what we expect them to do: Help themselves,” Williamson said.

When the winds get too fast, emergency responders will be grounded until conditions improve. Residents should prepare to fend for themselves for as long as 72 hours until the storms die down, he said.

The city’s major concern during storms is in the southeast quadrant because residents are on wells. If the power goes out, those residents won’t be able to get water pumped out of their wells.

“It doesn’t even take a storm to knock power out because if I had told you a week ago a snake will crawl into an electrical outlet or electrical component and black out 6,000 people you would have laughed at me,” Williamson said. Well, happened last week. So it doesn’t take a storm to cause problems.”

A snake caused a power outage after crawling into a Duke Energy facility on DeBary Avenue in Enterprise on Sunday, according to the Daytona Beach News-Journal.

Duke Energy said 6,131 customers, mostly DeBary-area ones, lost power at 9:42 p.m. and the outages lasted from 38 to 54 minutes.

Sign up for updates from DeBary Life:

Leave your comments below:


DeBary dog killer arrested for violations amid ‘cleansing ritual,’ records show


A DeBary man convicted of animal cruelty in the hanging death of his mom’s Chihuahua last year is behind bars again.

David Rivera, 25, is the man who underwent a “cleansing ritual” last month through the beheading sacrifice of chickens and other animals, records show.

No one was arrested for the sacrifice. But Rivera is on community control for the dog’s death and he was recently arrested for three probation violations.

Rivera is accused of failing to check in with his probation officer twice and moving without notifying officials.

He denied violating his probation during a hearing May 31, records show.

“The defendant is unstable and a threat to society,” a probation officer wrote in a report.

Rivera is being held without bond at the Volusia County Branch Jail in Daytona Beach.

A violation of probation hearing is set for June 21 before Circuit Court Judge James R. Clayton in DeLand.

Animal cruelty

Rivera entered a plea of no contest to a felony charge of animal cruelty after he was accused of hanging his mom’s dog in April 2016.

He was sentenced to five years of probation, according to records at the Volusia County Courthouse.

The attack on the dog happened April 14, 2016. Deputies were called to a home on Dirksen Drive about 11 a.m. that day.

Rivera’s mother told deputies she and her son had been arguing about his unemployment. She told him he would have to leave if he didn’t get a job, a spokesman for the Volusia County Sheriff’s Office said at the time.

During the argument, Rivera climbed an oak tree and hanged her 5-year-old male Chihuahua using a metal dog chain.

He then climbed about 30 feet up the same tree and threatened to hang himself. Deputies and the Sheriff’s Office Hostage Negotiation Team responded.

He gave up peacefully and came down after 8 hours.

‘Cleansing of bad spirits’

Last month, Rivera failed to check in with his probation officer, prompting officials to look for him.

Two probation officers went to his last known address — the house on Dirksen Drive — on May 16 and found Rivera with blood on his head, a report said.

“This officer inquired about the blood and was told he and other family friends were conducting a spiritual/ritual ceremony,” a report said. The ceremony involved “a cleansing of bad spirits and talking to the dead” and sacrifice of chickens.

Rivera led his probation officer to the place where the ritual cleansing was performed, according to clickorlando.com.

Numerous headless animals were found, along with family members, where the ritual was performed, an incident report said.

A bicyclist called 911 after finding a bin with these beheaded animals: five chickens, two pigeons, one goat and one turtle.

Rivera was involuntarily committed for a mental evaluation under the state’s Baker Act on May 17 after calling a probation officer and saying he wanted to kill himself.

Call to Rivera

On May 23, after Rivera missed another probation check-in, a probation officer went to the house on Dirksen Drive. No one answered then or during a second attempt that evening.

The officer went to a neighbor’s house, where the resident called Rivera while the officer stood by.

The officer spoke over the phone with Rivera, who said he “does not and cannot live” at the house on Dirksen Drive and has been staying with a friend.  The officer told Rivera to check-in at the probation office the next day, which he did.

He told the officer he had been living in a tent in Gemini Springs Park, an unverified claim. He also asked the officer if he could hear his thoughts.

The probation officer requested an arrest warrant for Rivera, saying he twice missed probation-office appointments and moved somewhere without notification.

David Rivera

Sign up for DeBary Life updates below:

Leave your comments below:

DeBary auto thieves put 1,500 miles on my SUV, victim says

Sue Kerkhof has been reunited with her 2016 Infiniti a week after it was stolen while pumping gas in DeBary.

But that week has been a busy one.

“They found my car 1 week and 1,500 miles later in an apt complex in Sanford,” Kerkhof, 60, of DeBary said on Facebook. “They drove the hell out of my beloved car!”

All of her personal belongings were gone. No arrests were announced. Authorities were not available for details over the Memorial Day holiday.

She praised all the police agencies that were involved, including the Volusia County Sheriff’s Office, Sanford police and Seminole County Sherrif’s Office.

The theft happened May 18.

A man who was loitering outside the store at 399 S. U.S. Highway 17-92 jumped behind the wheel at about 4:30 p.m.

She said the thief almost hit her with her own car as he headed south toward Sanford. She said she didn’t lock her car “because I was standing right there and if you lock it you can’t open the gas cap.”

Kerkhof said her insurance company and the Sanford Infiniti dealership are trying to “undo” the damage to the vehicle.

“It’s not wrecked but was abused and filthy and did have some damage,” she said recently in Facebook. “I have felt some pretty strong emotions and right now [and I] am mad that some of us work very hard for what we have and that someone feels free to steal it.”

DeBary woman: ‘I ran screaming after my car’

A 60-year-old DeBary woman said she is heartbroken after her car was stolen while she was pumping gas at the Kangaroo station at U.S. Highway 17-92 and Dirksen Drive on Thursday.

“My purse, phone and computer were in the car,” Sue Kerkhof said on Facebook. “I ran screaming after my car.”

The Volusia County Sheriff’s Office said the case is still active.

The white vehicle, a 2016 Infiniti QX50 SUV with a Florida State University vanity plates (SQ449), was taken by a man who was loitering outside the store at 399 S. U.S. Highway 17-92 at about 4:30 p.m., according to Kerkhof.

Kerkhof said the thief almost hit her with her own car as he headed south toward Sanford.

“I am mortified and sick that my personal information/purse, cell phone and bag and computer went with the sick sick…” she wrote. “I have never felt as helpless and sick.”

She wants her personal items returned.

“I had a piece of paper in my wallet that I have had from my son that passed away a year ago with the words Gam Gam on it in his writing,” she wrote. “Irreplaceable.”

She said she didn’t lock her car “because I was standing right there and if you lock it you can’t open the gas cap.”

She posted on the DeBary Proud page on Facebook.

“It can happen to any of us,” commented Facebook user Sally Dilts Chiodo. “It’s terrible that we have to look out for the scum of the earth when we walk out the door of our house. I am so sorry that it happened to you. Let’s all look out for each other.”

DeBary driveway repair scammer Gary Mitchell arrested, deputies say


The alleged driveway repair scammer who is accused of ripping off a 90-year-old DeBary woman has been arrested, officials said Friday.

Gary Mitchell, 29, was arrested in Broward County and brought to Volusia County, where he is being held in the Volusia County Branch Jail in Daytona Beach.

Mitchell is being held on a $50,000 bond, said Volusia County Sheriff’s Office spokesman Gary Davidson.

He was wanted on an arrest warrant for charges of elderly exploitation and scheme to defraud,

Mitchell pressured the woman into paying $3,000 for what turned out to be “shoddy and unprofessional work,” the Volusia County Sheriff’s Office said.

In January, Mitchell allegedly solicited the 90-year-old DeBary woman by “telling her that her driveway was in bad shape and then offering to resurface it,” Davidson said.

She initially said no. But then she eventually agreed after the man persisted.

She said the $3,000 price tag was too high but she wrote him a check anyway.

“Later that day, the woman became increasingly uneasy about the transaction and called her bank to try to stop payment on the check, but it had already been cashed,” Davidson said. “The check was written out to Mitchell, who was captured on surveillance video cashing it at the bank.”

Experts said it appeared that her driveway “had been painted over with a watered-down concrete mix and that the material was applied incorrectly and is of very poor quality and the work was grossly overpriced,” Davidson said.

Detectives think Mitchell also tried to scam an 88-year-old DeBary man.

Mitchell was convicted in Arizona of financial exploitation of a vulnerable adult.